Related
Working Paper
/ Sep 02,2014
Up or Out?
Examining the Trade-offs of Urban Form
Event
/ Nov 07,2013
Paul Collier on Housing Policy in Africa
+ Brandon Fuller
As the populations of cities in the developing world grow, the cities themselves will sprawl outward. But “sprawl” in this context doesn’t need to become a dirty word.
My colleague Solly Angel estimates that, in the year 2000, average urban density was 23 people per hectare (p/ha) in land-rich developed countries like the U.S. Because the density threshold is estimated to be 50 p/ha for metro service and 30 p/ha for bus service, there’s a reasonable case to be made that American cities should densify. But at 136 p/ha in the year 2000, it’s safe to say that average urban density is far higher in the developing world. In many cases, urban density can therefore decline sharply without posing a threat to sustainable forms of transportation.
Indeed, as a recent editorial in the Tanzania Daily News makes clear, concerns about too much density in the developing world will often loom much larger than those about too little. Where overcrowding creates health and safety hazards, the authors find the benefits of declining density to be quite large:
Diseases associated with unsanitary conditions prevail in these congested places where squatters, mainly the poor, live in filthy conditions with no clean piped water. Swarms of houseflies roam at will spreading diseases.It is these unsanitary conditions that are often the source of numerous fast killer diseases such as cholera, dysentery and typhoid which, invariably, erupt where communities do not have good pit latrines, toilets, lavatories or generally, reliable waste disposal systems.
The piece mentions Paul Collier’s call for the abolition of the Town and Country Planning Act of 1947 in former British colonies. Collier has written about the Act before, arguing that it brings with it building standards and minimum plot sizes that are far too high given current income levels in Sub-Saharan Africa. Enforcement of the Act makes formal housing inaccessible for the poor, pushing large numbers of urban newcomers into informal housing developments where overcrowding and the lack of sanitation tend to be most pronounced.
The construction of healthy and affordable housing will require realistic building regulations and sufficient room for urban expansion, both of which can coexist with the viability of mass transit in the cities of the developing world.